All stories

Edible BrandsGift baskets and fruit arrangements

At Edible Brands, AI shoppers spend more but convert less

Gifting retailer Edible Brands told Digital Commerce 360 that orders from AI visitors are $5.50 bigger than its site average. But those visitors convert at more than 5%, below the site's usual rate of more than 10%.

  • $5.50higher average order value from AI traffic than the site average
  • 5%+conversion rate from AI traffic, below a site average of more than 10%
  • 95%of AI referral traffic comes from ChatGPT (about)

The good part

Edible Brands is a large US gifting retailer, No. 182 in the Digital Commerce 360 Top 1000. Chief digital officer Erica Randerson said AI is still a small slice of its traffic, less than 10%, and ChatGPT accounts for about 95% of it.

Those shoppers spend more. The average order from AI traffic is $5.50 greater than the site average, and Randerson said AI traffic seems a little more immune to the pull of lower-priced goods.

“But I will say: That's lower than our site average.”

Erica Randerson, chief digital officer at Edible Brands

The less good part

AI visitors convert at more than 5%, which Randerson called strong. But it is lower than Edible's site average of more than 10%. She put that high average down to the kind of store Edible is: people arrive to buy a gift, usually knowing who it is for.

“We have a high intent audience. They're coming in knowing who they're shopping for most of the time.”

Erica Randerson, chief digital officer at Edible Brands

What other stores can take from this

  1. Compare AI shoppers with your own average. At Edible they looked strong on their own but converted below the site's usual rate.
  2. Know your baseline. Edible's regular shoppers already arrive with a clear goal, which is why its normal conversion rate is so high.
  3. Look at order value too. Even with lower conversion, Edible's AI orders were $5.50 bigger on average.

Worth knowing: A mixed result: AI shoppers spend a little more per order but convert below the site's usual rate. Results like this vary from store to store.

Source

“How AI referrals are impacting traffic at 4 online retailers”

Digital Commerce 360 · Abbas Haleem · 16 September 2026

Read the original article (opens in a new tab)

Edible Brands is not a GEO customer. This page is our summary of Digital Commerce 360's reporting. The figures and quotes are theirs.

See all stories

Want to see if ChatGPT recommends your products? Try our free AI Visibility Checker.